Movements to end mass incarceration are gaining momentum, and reform efforts seek to change counterproductive tough-on-crime laws and policies. But the punishment of so many people for such long periods of time is driven not only by official policies but also by judicial practices that have become institutionalized over time. Focusing on monetary sanctions (fines and fees) and money bail, this Essay argues that it is often courts’ practices, their interpretation and implementation of the law, that shape outcomes in criminal legal systems rather than the dictates of law and policy alone.