In Utah v. Strieff, the Supreme Court held that where an unconstitutional detention leads to the discovery of a valid arrest warrant, the Fourth Amendment does not generally require suppression of evidence seized incident to that arrest, applying Brown v. Illinois’s multifactor attenuation test. This Comment argues that narrowly focused adjudicatory tests like the one from Brown are poor instruments for the exclusionary rule’s regulatory analysis. The costs and benefits of suppression should be weighed in a broad factual context that also considers exclusionary rule precedent already in effect. (Published as an unsigned student case comment.)